State house race results to be certified Wednesday; Republican candidates challenge some provisional votes

Wood County Board of Elections meeting Tuesday morning John Cuckler (left to right), Ryan Rothenbuhler, Terry Burton, Julie Baumgardner, Andy Newlove and Zack Schmidt.

By JAN McLAUGHLIN

BG Independent News

The results in Wood County’s state representative races remain in limbo at least for one more day.

The Wood County Board of Elections met Tuesday morning to rule on provisional ballots – resulting in the rejection of 213 ballots and acceptance of 1,144 ballots.

Those ballots will be counted today, with totals to be certified by the board on Wednesday at 8:30 a.m.

The races for the two Ohio House seats remain too close to call – resulting in a last minute effort to disqualify some provisional ballots cast by citizens in Wood County.

On Monday, the Wood County Board of Elections received a four-page letter from a law firm on behalf of two Republican state representative candidates – Haraz Ghanbari of House District 75, and Edward Schimmel of House District 44.

The Cincinnati law firm stated the board of elections should reject the ballots of some voters who had moved to Wood County from other counties in Ohio, and had not updated their registrations.

The letter said that citizens who cast their provisional ballots at their new precinct polling places should be disqualified because they didn’t vote at the board of elections or at a board-designated site. The law firm argued that people who moved from one Ohio county to another, who didn’t update their registrations before the deadline, are only eligible to cast a provisional ballot at the board of elections office or a board designated site – and not at a neighborhood precinct polling place.

The letter, sent on Nov. 16 on behalf of Ghanbari and Schimmel, asked the board of elections to provide the number of those citizens in writing, by precinct, no later than Nov. 16. The legal counsel said the board should vote to reject those ballots as ineligible.

However, the Wood County Board of Elections proceeded as it has in the past, in accordance with the Ohio Secretary of State directive that such ballots be counted and certified, an elections official stated.

The same objection was also filed with Lucas County Board of Elections, which on Monday also rejected the request.

On Tuesday morning, the Wood County Board of Elections called its meeting to order, then immediately went into executive session for discussions with its legal counsel. Fifteen minutes later, the board returned to its public meeting and began deliberating on the legitimacy of the 1,357 provisional ballots cast in Wood County.

After reviewing all the provisional ballots, the board voted to reject 213, and accept 1,144.

The number of “fatally flawed provisional ballots” rejected this morning included:

  • 101 voters who were not registered in Ohio.
  • 9 voters who were registered in Ohio but who voted in the wrong precinct and wrong polling location.
  • 17 voters who did not provide a date of birth.
  • 19 voters who presented insufficient information to the precinct, specifically a Wood County address.
  • 12 voters who had already voted.
  • 47 voters who did not provide valid identification.
  • 8 voters who did not provide a signature.

Much of Wood County is included in the 75th House District, while the northeastern corner of the county is in the 44th House District. In both of those races, the Republicans hold slight leads.

The unofficial vote count in the 75th House District has incumbent Republican Haraz Ghanbari, with 23,193 votes (50.14%) leading by 126 votes to Democrat Rick Rettig with 23,067 votes (49.86%).

It is likely the majority of the provisional ballots are in the 75th District since many were cast in the Bowling Green State University precinct.

The race in House District 44 in northern Wood County is split by just 56 votes. Republican Ed Schimmel currently has 47.97% of the vote, while Democrat David Fournier has 47.87%, a difference of 56 votes, with independent Lindsey Stough pulling about 4% of the vote. That district includes parts of Wood, Lucas  and Ottawa counties.

A recount will be automatically triggered if the tallies are within 0.5% of the votes cast in races.