Ohio lawmakers approve cellphones in school measure; bill directs districts to draft policy to minimize use

State Sen. Andrew Brenner, R-Delaware, speaks during the Ohio Senate session, June 7, 2023, at the Statehouse in Columbus, Ohio. (Photo by Graham Stokes for Ohio Capital Journal)

BY NICK EVANS

Ohio Capital Journal

Ohio lawmakers signed off on changes to the military seal for high school diplomas on Wednesday. But the bill’s most notable provision was a last minute amendment regarding cellphones in K-12 schools that caught a ride on the non-controversial measure.

Recently, Gov. Mike DeWine urged lawmakers to address cellphones in classrooms during his state of the state address. Now, about a month later, those changes are headed to his desk.

Some lawmakers casually refer to the changes as a “cellphone ban,” but that’s a bit of a misnomer. Instead, the law directs every district to develop a written policy aimed at minimizing phone use during school hours and potential distractions during class instruction.

The bill also includes an exception for students who need a phone to assist in learning or to track a health concern, so long as it is reflected in their individual education plan.

On the Senate floor, the cellphone provision’s chief backer, Sen. Andrew Brenner, R-Delaware, explained “the legislation does not require districts to adopt a ban on all students’ cell phone use, though that is an option if the school district chooses to do so.”

He added that those districts with cellphone policies in place don’t need to change them so long as the policy “emphasize(s) minimal use and least amount of distraction.”

“The language also directs the Department of Education and Workforce to develop a model policy informed by evidence-based research on the effects of smartphones and classrooms, that districts may choose to adopt as their policy if they wish to do so,” Brenner said.

Newly sworn in State Rep. Beryl Brown Piccolantonio, D-Gahanna. (Photo by Graham Stokes for Ohio Capital Journal)

Across the hall in the House, Rep. Tracy Richardson, R-Marysville, emphasized how their approach gives districts direction without being prescriptive.

“Each school district is required to create their own policy, thus ensuring — and let me make this very clear — local control,” she said.

Up until this January, Rep. Beryl Piccolantonio, D-Gahanna, was serving as president of the Gahanna-Jefferson School Board, and she described the changes as “critically important.”

“A frequent issue that was raised to us by staff, and by students, quite frankly, was how difficult it was for staff to enforce their own classroom policies because they didn’t have broader support to back up that enforcement.”

She praised the measure for giving districts the “flexibility” to develop their own approaches to deal with the issue. Highlighting a recent take your child to work day event where kids debated cellphones in schools, she noted “even some of the students acknowledge the distraction that cellphones have within their classroom.”

More headlines from Ohio Capital Journal

Ohio AG investigating alleged ‘hostile takeover’ inside teacher’s pension fund

Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost has launched an investigation into the teacher’s pension fund after allegations that a “hostile takeover” is putting educators’ money in jeopardy.

The State Teachers Retirement System of Ohio (STRS) is a $90 billion pension fund — and has been involved in controversy for years. READ MORE

Ohio lawmakers insist Biden will be on November’s ballot, but they’re fuzzy on details

In a surprise move, the Ohio House decided not to take up legislation to ensure President Joe Biden appears on the November ballot in Ohio.

But elected leaders from both parties insist Biden will appear on voters’ ballots. They have said so many times. But the thing is, they’re not exactly sure how, and an obscure provision in state law gives them a deadline they may not be able to meet.

Ohio law provides that political parties must certify their candidates with the Secretary of State “on or before” the 90th day prior to an election. The Democratic National Convention, the meeting at which the party will officially nominate Biden, won’t happen until August 22 — 75 days prior to the election.

This week, lawmakers hammered out two competing proposals, one in the House and one in the Senate, that would push that deadline to 74 days instead. 

But because laws passed without an emergency clause don’t take effect for 90 days, lawmakers inadvertently gave themselves a deadline of May 9 to get the measure signed, sealed and delivered.  READ MORE